Search This Blog

Translate This Page

Total Pageviews

Showing posts with label Joseph. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Joseph. Show all posts

Friday, October 9, 2026

How Many Women Were at the Foot of the Cross?

 The koine/common Greek used in the Bible was written without any punctuation, had no spaces between words, and was written in one long stream. This, and especially the lack of punctuation marks like commas, periods, colons, and semicolons, requires the modern reader sometimes to make assumptions as to the exact literal meaning. After centuries of scholarly study, this is not known to have ever obscured the theological messages being presented.

This is present in the question of exactly how many women were at the foot of the cross? Were there three or were there four? Depending on how they are identified there could have been more than four. We do know that more women were present but were standing farther back. 

These women standing farther back probably included Joanna (Luke 8:2-3, 24:10), who was the wife of Chuza, who was the personal steward of Herod Antipas.

Women were strongly attracted to Jesus. They lived in a totally male-dominated world but he treated them with actual respect as if they had brains and were actual people.

John was at the foot of the cross with the women (John 19:26-27) but where were all the other men? Well, they ran away or were hanging farther back into the crowd which was there to see the crucifixion. They were afraid. Matthew 26:56

A literal, word-for-word translation of Matthew 27:55-56: Were and / now there women many from afar off / a distance beholding / looking on who / which had followed to the Jesus from the Galilee ministering to / serving Him in / among whom was Mary the Magdalene and Mary the of James and Joseph / Joses mother and the mother of the sons Zebedee (four women)

A literal, word-for-word translation of Mark 15:40-41: They were and / now also women from / out of afar off / a distance beholding / looking on / observing in whom also / both Mary the Magdalene and Mary the of James the little / younger / less and of Joses / Joseph mother and Salome who when he was in the Galilee were following him and were ministering to / serving him and other many the ones having come up with him into / to Jerusalem (four women)

A literal, word-for-word translation of Luke 23:27: Was following / was trailing behind and / now / moreover to Him / Him much / great / large crowd / multitude / crowded mass of the people and of women who / which were beating themselves / were lamenting and were wailing / were mourning / singing dirges Him (The number of women is not stated and they are not individually named)

A literal, word-for-word translation of John 19:23-25: they had stood / were standing now / and / but beside / near / by the cross / stake of the of Jesus the mother of him / his and the sister of the of mother of him / his Mary the of the of Clopas / Cleopas and Mary the Magdalene / of Magdala (Either three or four women depending on whether or not Mary, the wife of Cleophas, was the sister of Mary, Jesus’ mother. The word could also mean female relative, especially since some traditions say that Cleophas/Clopas was Joseph’s brother)

The women who are mentioned include:

Jesus’mother, Mary (Miryam, Miriam)

Mary’s sister (possibly Salome, or Mary who was the wife of Clopas, or a different woman entirely)

Mary, the wife of Clopas/Cleophas. Tradition says that Clopas was the brother of Joseph.

Salome, who may have been the sister who is mentioned above. Tradition says she was the mother of the apostles James and John.

Mary the Magdalene

Mary, the mother of James the Less

The mother of the sons of Zebedee

You sort them out. This is like a situation which genealogists often run into while tracing family ancestry. Often in one small community there are several men of the same name and roughly of the same age. It can be difficult. 

Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus showed up to claim Jesus’ body for burial after he was declared to be dead. John 19:38-40

Remember that the New Testament is written in the Greek which was in common everyday use at that time. The contemporary readers would have understood exactly what was being said. We are the ones with the problem.

The fact that the four recountings of this event are not exactly word-for-word identical shows that the Gospels, while God-inspired, were written by four different men with different writing styles and different levels of proficiency in Greek and that God used each man to say what God wanted to be said. 

Wednesday, December 25, 2024

We Three Kings of Orient Are

 

 “We Three Kings” (original title: “Three Kings of Orient”) is a Christmas carol written in 1857 by John henry Hopkins, an Episcopal rector in Pennsylvania. It is based on Matthew 2:1.

The Bible never says that three kings visited Jesus in a manger on the night of his birth. John and Mark do not mention the incident at all because they talked about Jesus as an adult. Luke talks of the shepherds but not the magi. Only Matthew, in 2:1-16, relates the event, saying that during the time of Herod, who died in 4 BC/BCE, that magi “from the rising of the sun” (the east) arrived to see and worship the king of the Jews, whose star they had seen.

Several questions come to mind:

1.      Who were the magi and how many of them were there?

No one knows exactly who these men were but many later traditions say that they were possibly astrologers from a learned priestly Zoroastrian caste in Persia. They were not occultists but were considered to be masters of the then current understanding of science.                                                     

The idea that there were three wise men possibly derives from the fact that they brought three gifts: gold. Frankincense, and myrrh. Some Christian traditions say that there were twelve magi.

2.      What was the star?

No one really knows. Was it a supernaturally moving star that settled over Jesus’ location? (Matthew 2:9). Was it an otherwise unknown comet? Was it a conjunction of Jupiter and Saturn (7 BC/BCE) or of Saturn and Venus (6 BC/BCE)? Was it a transient astronomical event like a distant supernova? (The first historically documented supernova observation did not occur until 1006 AD/CE).

3.      Where did the magi visit Jesus?

The wise men came to see Jesus in a house “oikian” (οἰκίαν, Matthew 2:11), not in a manger “phatne” (φάτνῃ, Luke 2:7).

4.      How old was Jesus when the magi arrived?

Luke 2:1-16 describes how, on the night of Jesus’ birth, angels appeared to announce the birth to shepherds who ran to the stable to see the “brephos” (βρέφος). A “brephos” was an unborn child, newborn child, or an infant.

Matthew 2:1-18 relates that that the magi visited the “paidion” (παιδίον) in a house. A “paidion” is a young one, a little one, or a child.

After a message from God warned them about Herod the magi returned home by a different route. Matthew 2:16-18 tells how Herod, in a fit of anger, jealousy, and insecurity about losing his position as king of Judea, ordered what is now known as the massacre of the Innocents. All boys under two years old and younger living in the area in or near Bethlehem were to be slaughtered.

Matthew 2:13-16 tells how God warned Joseph of Herod’s evil plan to kill Jesus. Joseph left for Egypt with Jesus and Mary.

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

Are You Bored With Your Life?

If we are bored with life there is something wrong with our concept of God and His involvement in our daily lives.  Even the most dull and tedious days of our lives are ordained by God and ought to be used by us to glorify Him."  Jerry Bridges, The Navigators

Every job is meaningful, every life is meaningful.  God may have you in place to perform one action in His plan for the life of one person, or numerous persons.  You may never know what you have done.  How do you know that you have not already done it?

Joseph probably was not thrilled when his brothers sold him into slavery.  He was being placed into a position in which he could save his people.  Esther probably was not thrilled to be forced to become essentially a sexual slave for a brutal king.  She was in position to save her people from genocide. Brother Lawrence was an uneducated man not suited for any monastery duties except cooking and washing dishes.  He cheerfully devoted his duties to the Lord and became known worldwide for his pious example.