Automated License Plate Reader Cameras

 This blog is ακωλυτως, unhindered. (Acts 28:31) Any subject is fair game. We are allowed to have and to express opinions on any subject. 

While it is not explicitly a Christian subject, the confidentiality of your personal information is a very important thing you do need to consider.

Governments and the legal systems of countries are usually about ten years behind the rapid developments of science and technology. This causes intense controversy over numerous subjects such as information data centers, artificial intelligence systems, the usage of aborted fetal remains in the treatment of diseases, establishing the age of viability of developing unborn children, and automated license plate reader cameras. 

Flock safety automated license plate reader cameras have sparked a nationwide, bipartisan debate over public safety versus mass surveillance and civil liberties.

Law enforcement agencies insist that the cameras are important in tracking criminal suspects and stolen vehicles, and in locating possibly kidnapped persons.

One argument is this: Automobile license plates and vehicle exteriors are exposed to the public and, so, are in the public domain. Because of this, drivers in public view cannot claim privacy rights about their automobiles or location.

Critics of this view claim that a surveillance state is being created and they present evidence of abuses such as police officers who are accused of inappropriately using the database to track personal movements of persons not involved in criminal investigations. A public backlash against use of the cameras has erupted, including the criminal act of vandalism against the cameras.

Lack of Privacy:

Does everyone carry around a cell phone in their pocket? Every cellphone in the world is locatable using a global positioning system. Why is everyone not concerned about that?

A suggestion:

I worked for almost 50 years in hospital clinical laboratories and we were constantly reminded about patient confidentiality. We had access to extremely personal information about criminal suspects, politicians, celebrities, regular people from our communities, and even our own family members. All of these people deserved to have their personal information securely protected. Those of us who failed in this responsibility were subject to instant dismissal from their jobs.

In 1996, the United States federal government stepped in with the passage of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). After a short time-period which allowed the affected institutions the time necessary for them to put the standards into effect, full enforcement of the law began in April of 2003.

Enforcement against violations of the HIPAA law is totally inflexible. The penalties include total exclusion from any government contracts of any sort, massive monetary fines enacted for each violation, and very long prison terms for each violation. A Basic Metabolic Panel laboratory test usually is comprised of eight components. Release of these results could be seen as eight separate violations.

Access to the collected information should be legally restricted to police and governmental entities only.

If HIPAA level punishments were attached to the misuse of surveillance cameras, the problem might be quickly resolved. And they could still be used for legitimate purposes.

Should Christians Fear Artificial Intelligence?

 AI is a computer program that looks at patterns in data. It has no emotions or personal identity, even though the most advanced programs can carry on a conversation with you and refer to themselves as I.

AI can find obscure information almost instantly, translate between numerous languages simultaneously, whether they are spoken or written, and can create lifelike voices and images in seconds. Many people have begun to use it to enhance their Bible study. Tilly Norwood is a completely computer-generated actress who is now beginning to appear in motion pictures. Yes, AI can be a powerful tool.

We should not fear AI itself. It is not a conscious being, but is actually just numerous extremely fast computer programs which have been trained to mimic human behavior and speech. That is one of the concerns: it was trained by humans. You know about humans.

Rather than fear the computer programs, we need to be careful and wise about them. They can be used by criminals or malevolent persons to create fake videos, spread lies, or steal data. Some evil persons have created pornographic videos featuring the faces of innocent persons to whom they wish to cause embarrassment and harm. Some evil persons have used AI to mine and steal other peoples personal financial or private data. Some actors are afraid that their images and voices may be used to produce films in which they were not actually involved, costing them money, career choices, and personal reputation. Faked videos could conceivably be used to implicate innocent persons in crimes.

Just pay attention. Be as wise as a serpent and as innocent as a dove.

Choosing a Charity to Support

             Charity in the Bible is presented as “love in action,” not as a means of earning salvation but as a result of having been given the gift of salvation.  There are thousands of charities and, as we are financially able, we may donate to one or to many as we see fit. One caveat: for a Christian, our main purpose should be to advance the kingdom. Any other purposes, even those which are obviously positive, are secondary. 

            ἕκαστος καθὼς προῄρηται τῇ καρδίᾳ, μὴ ἐκ λύπης ἢ ἐξ ἀνάγκης· ἱλαρὸν γὰρ δότην ἀγαπᾷ ὁ Θεός 2 Corinthians 9:7, in a literal translation into English would read something like this: Every/each as he has decided in heart, not out of grudging or out of forced need/necessity, cheerful indeed giver loves God. Read this verse in your own preferred Bible translation.

            Not all charities are ethical and some border on actual fraud. Some give very limited funds to the causes they espouse, instead using most of their money for “administrative expenses.” Others resort to questionable practices to raise funds. They may send you a set of address labels or some small gift to make you feel a sense of obligation to them.

The website shown below discusses donor’s hesitance to contribute to charities which violate the donor’s privacy by selling their names and contact information to third parties. There are actually companies which sell targeted mailing lists of persons known to have donated to similar charities. For example, a person could be targeted for their history of donating to charities dedicated to a particular political orientation, or to a specific religious group, or to animal rescue activities, or to anti- or pro-abortion groups, or to foster involvement in the arts, or to literacy programs, or to homeless or injured veteran’s activities, or to  advance children’s sports involvement, or to disaster relief organizations, or to charities which are medically oriented. There is an established charity for almost any imaginable purpose and you can safely assume that most of them are willing to sell the contact information of their donors and to buy targeted lists of prospective new donors. They, and hundreds of others, will flood you with sometimes very insistent requests for donations.  On https://smartasset.com you can also read this article, “The 50 Worst Charities in America.”

https://www.workplaceprivacyreport.com/2022/03/articles/online-privacy/not-for-profits-charities-might-attract-more-donors-with-improved-website-content-attention-to-privacy/

This is unethical and is presumptuous, as if you owe your money to their particular charity. It exhibits an extreme disrespect for their donors but is not illegal and at least some of the donated funds go to their stated causes.

Favor Christian charities as your first choices. Give to secular charities if you have even more to give. Research your chosen charity’s mission statement carefully to make sure that they actually provide the majority of their funds to their stated purpose.  Some charities explicitly state that they respect their donors and that they do not sell your personal information to others. God loves a cheerful giver but he also expects us to use our gift of discernment. Use your money wisely to advance the Kingdom.

A few Bible verses about charity: Deuteronomy 15:11; Proverbs 14:21, 19:17; Malachi 3:10; Matthew 5:42, 6:1-2, 19:21; Luke 6:38, 11:41, 12:33; John 3:17; Acts 9:36, 20:35; Hebrews 13:16; Romans 12:13; Colossians 3:14; 1 Timothy 1:5; 1 John 3:17; James 2:15-16.